‘Britney Vs Spears’ film review: A toxic and troubling take on a controversial conservatorship

I wakened this morning to the fist-pumping information that Britney Spears’ father Jamie has been suspended as conservator. This was a few days after I had powered by way of the unwatchable Britney Vs Spears on Netflix – an expertise that made my pores and skin crawl.

Additionally Learn | Get ‘First Day First Present’, our weekly publication from the world of cinema, in your inbox. You may subscribe at no cost right here

I went into Britney Vs Spears with excessive hopes for a few causes; the primary being that Netflix does its justifiable share of excellent documentaries, and the second being the Britney Spears conservatorship deserves all of the progressive press it has acquired. However I missed the main crimson flag earlier than its launch; the truth that Netflix debuted the trailer just some days earlier than its launch. I’ve seen a sample – and be at liberty to disagree – of Netflix shunting last-minute trailers for tasks the platform shouldn’t be precisely proud to name its personal.

Whereas The New York Instances Presents documentary Framing Britney Spears by Samantha Stark employed a feminist lens to look at the conservatorship, Vice contributor Carr takes a considerably extra salacious flip with Britney Vs Spears. The previous was not acquired nicely by Spears who mentioned she cried for 2 weeks after watching it. She additionally known as the BBC’s documentary The Battle for Britney: Followers, Money and a Conservatorship hypocritical.

Learn Extra | ‘Framing Britney Spears’ overview: We all know why the caged pop star sings

These unauthorised documentaries are understandably ill-received… however for Britney Vs Spears, the musician got here ahead and mentioned it left her scratching her head and she or he shamed the unclassy dialogue. So, we’re off to an excellent begin.

Within the movie, as legal professional Tony Chicotel so bluntly places it, a conservatorship is “a civil dying”, the final resort that’s applied solely when the circumstances are past anybody’s management. For 13 years, Spears was subjected to not simply monitoring her funds but additionally having her reproductive rights taken away from her and her personal dwelling bugged in bedrooms and loos. Her psychological well being struggles have been made into punny headlines to promote magazines and clicks.

Whereas all this might have been portrayed respectfully, Carr and her workforce as a substitute undertake a shock worth posture. Calling this a documentary could be the best praise.

Britney Vs Spears reeks of ‘think about somebody made a movie with individuals who have been unhealthy for Britney’. Whereas it absolutely aimed to reply numerous questions posed after the NYT documentary, the OMG tone of all of it overshadowed what may have been a productive watch.

There’s a lot about Britney Vs Spears that doesn’t sit proper.

Within the movie’s try and be diplomatic, it veered into trash speak territory with a very dramatic rating. Spears’ divorce from Kevin Federline was handled with an insultingly tabloid tone, furthering the discourse that the singer was maybe truly not able to being a mom in any respect. Workforce that with visuals of Rosie O’Donnell cheering concerning the divorce and it leaves a foul style in your mouth.

One other huge query mark: why was BreathHeavy.com’s founder featured? Did we actually want the ‘skilled’ opinion of a tabloid to grasp what rather more dependable information media had reported?

Carr’s readability of objective will be seen, nevertheless it leaves the movie vulnerable to hyperbole – relatively dangerous in a public case like this one. It’s also too simple to really feel as if this served as an arrogance undertaking’s of Carr’s, notably along with her and Rolling Stone journalist Jenny Eliscu sat in entrance of a desk like true crime podcasters, piecing all the pieces collectively.

Frankly, this could not have been made. Like Britney, I used to be scratching my head – after I was not rolling my eyes or shaking my head in disgust. As for Netflix… nicely, it doesn’t all the time get it proper, I assume.